[Pastor Ralph]

Q5. (Judges 7:5-6) What significance, if any, do you see in selecting the "lappers" from the "kneelers"?

[Mario Angel]

Before I answer this question I checked some of the comments of different authors, like these ones:

Quote

a. Why did God use this way of testing the troops? Perhaps because those who would cup the water to their hands and bring it to their mouths would be better soldiers, because they could keep their eyes on their surroundings even when taking a drink

David Guzik Study Guide

When the wandering people in Asia, on a journey or in haste, come to water, they do not stoop down with deliberation on their knees, but only bend forward as much as is necessary to bring their hand in contact with the stream, and throw it up with rapidity, and at the same time such address, that they do not drop a particle. The Israelites, it seems, were acquainted with the practice; and those who adopted it on this occasion were selected as fit for a work that required expedition. The rest were dismissed according to the divine direction. Robert Jamieson, A. R. Fausset and David Brown Commentary

We must suppose they were all thirsty, and were inclined to drink; it is likely he told them they must prepare to enter upon action immediately, and therefore must refresh themselves accordingly, not expecting, after this, to drink any thing else but the blood of their enemies. Now some, and no doubt the most, would kneel down on their knees to drink, and put their mouths to the water as horses do, and so they might get their full draught. Others, it may be, would not make such a formal business of it, but as a dog laps with his tongue, a lap and away, so they would hastily take up a little water in their hands, and cool their mouths with that, and be gone. Matthew Henry Commentary

Now it is hard to distinguis which was the real reason that God used to choose the 300 men, but seems like the ability of those who were choosed to stand quicker and be ready faster to attack the enemy, was the major reason for been choosed by God.

[Omie]

+ If God wanted us to understand the reason I believe the author, which may have been Samuel would have given us some indication. I have studied this before. I find no answer!

[DEBORAH]

Q5. I FIND NO ANSWER AT THIS TIME.
WELL THE LAPPERS DID NOT LEAVE THEMSELVES VULNERBLE, FOR ATTACK.

[Peggie]

The only answer I can come up with is that the lappers may have been those who would be more alert.

[Wendy Reid]

Only God knows the real answer on this one, but isn't is exciting that only the lappers were exactly the number that God had ordained to defeat the Midianites.

[Darleen Nelson]

The only significance that I see was that this was God's way of selection and Gideon didn't question it. God would be recognized as the source of such a great victory and Gideon was obedient in choosing the members to participate in just the way the Lord told him to choose them.

[Elwood C O'Dell]

[FONT=Arial][SIZE=7][COLOR=blue]Might this now just fit into one of those times when we have to remind ourselves that God's thoughts and ways are not our thoughts and ways. That his ways are higher than our ways, his thoughts higher than our thoughts and sometimes He has His reason(s) for what he does and expects of us that really isn't any of our business. He really doesn't have to explain and sometimes we probably don't need to understand. Just trust Him.

[Fina]

I don't see any significance in selecting the "lappers" from the "kneelers." God wants only to reduce the size of the army so that Israel would not boast against Him, that it is He who saved them.

[Chris]

The significance between selecting lappers as opposed to Kneelers I feel is purely with regard to "Being prepared". I say this because the lappers were more likely to be aware of their surroundings while drinking and be able to see all that was going on around them, whereas the kneelers would not be fully aware of their surroundings. The difference between these two with regard to either being a member of an army is that the former would be more alert in their actions, whereas the latter due to their lack of alertness could put the rest of the army in danger.

[Andrew]

Lappers are thought to be ever prepared for the unexpected so they drink water while prepared at a moments notice. That should be the way we should be with God, ever prepared at a moments notice.

[Helen Williams]

Lappers----Aware of our surrondings. We are in a spiritual warfare. Even though we are about our daily duties, we should always stay spiritual focus. Satan is out to deceive and destroy. Let us stay alert.

Kneelers---God doesn't want us to be so busy with things of this world that we are not aware of our spiritual welfare. We are soliders on the battle field for the Lord.

[Vickie]

If you picture the scene, perhaps there is an answer. Imagine 300 men kneeling, as if in prayer to our Lord. Now, imagine the other 9,700 (10,000 remained after the fearful were sent home) prostrating themselves on the ground bent over at the waist as the heathens do to worship their gods (ref. the Muslims, Hindus, Buddhists, etc.). And, just as there are only a handful of true Christians in the world compared with the heathen, there were just a handful of the "kneelers" left.

I don't know if this is correct, but the imagery struck me.

[Helen Spaulding]

I agree with the majority that those who lapped were more ready for
whatever might happen while they were assuaging their thirst.
They would be able to see what was going on around them and thus not
be surprised by an enemy. Since most people would think this was a
break from the fighting, they would be more apt to take it easy, kneeling
down to drink by putting their face down to the water. That way, they could
not be as aware of who or what came near them. They would miss those
precious moments that could mean life or death to them. So, since God
wanted soldiers who would be "in uniform" all the time, and since, even
more importantly, He wanted the force to be so small that the people
would recognize that the conqueror was God Himself, He used this method
to separate the majority and send them home. When God is on our side--
or rather, when we are on His side--the number is immaterial!

[Mark]

I can only surmise that the lappers were those that would be more alert during a time that they might be vunerable to attack. Those that are trained in the martial arts would be more likely to be aware and on guard while drinking rather than put themselves into a kneeling position to drink where they could be easily overcome by an enemy. We will never know the real reason God chose this method of separating the men.

[photobug]

we are in a war and the lappers were more alert than the knelers they could be on the look out more i think

[DebChats]

I do not know why God told Gideon to choose the lappers as opposed to the kneelers. I wondered which one I would be if I were there. I suppose I would be a lapper if I were not all that thirsty. However, I would kneel if extremely thirsty. This does not answer the question .. but is interesting.

[Linda Stanley]

Pastor Ralph, on Jan 24 2003, 09:23 AM, said:

Q5. What significance, if any, do you see in selecting the "lappers" from the "kneelers"? See Exposition and Footnote 11

With God wanting to reduce the army to a smaller size,God instructed Gideon on how the men were to be chosen.So Gideon took the men down to the water.The lappers were more alert and aware what was going on around them as they scooped or cuped the water in their hand.The ones kneeling and lapping like dogs did not pass the test.With your face down and lapping water there was a great chance you would be slain by the enemy,but that was really not Gods purpose,God new what He was doing.Now the Lord told Gideon with the 300 men that lapped water in there hands, I will save you and give the Midianites into your hands.To me God was fullfilling His promise to Gideon,and Gideon was obeying and trusting God.,

[nelda huffman]

Lappers were the ones who were more prepared for whatever happened unexpectethe lneelersd or otherwise and just maybe God decided the kneelers could stay and pray for the lappers while they fought. Who knows for sure. Should we really be questioning why God does what he does? NO! I think not. Only he knows why?

[Marjorie Knight]

I'm not sure what the signifigance is, but
I feel that the kneelers would have been ill prepared for any danger.
Only God knows.